What is it like to negotiate with Moscow's officials concerning the war in Ukraine?
This inquiry has generated considerable curiosity following several latest sessions of peace discussions, which have so far appeared to produce little fruit half a decade after Russia's full-scale military offensive.
A further phase of US-mediated negotiations is expected to occur in Geneva later this week. In preparation, a key participant of the Ukrainian leadership's delegation, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has taken part in recent military-to-military talks, has shared his perspective.
According to the negotiator, these interactions are business-like and mostly devoid of the sort of political and historical grandstanding observed in other forums by Moscow.
"Military officials have a superior understanding of the realities in the battlefield," he remarked in a conversation earlier this week.
"It's another thing if they [the Russians] are able, or not, of relaying information directly…without cooking or changing the information," he continued.
It is far from an simple task to try to end a major conflict. The nature of the front line in eastern Ukraine - where tens of thousands of unmanned aerial vehicles patrol and kill over a vast so-called "contested area" separating the two sides, while two hundred thousand Ukrainian civilians still reside in the "heavily fortified" cities of the Donbas - renders the technical process of disengagement extremely complicated.
"You have to have a clear set of guidelines and procedures," Kyslytsya said, "and a way to verify and oversee."
The Involvement of International Mediators
A great deal of this work, he noted, is complete, thanks in part to the close participation of American representatives, such as a senior NATO commander and a high-ranking Army official.
Clearly not in Kyiv's benefit to criticise envoys of the American government, but when he compliments the American team for its work, he comes across as sincere.
"We have to acknowledge the Americans for their commitment and their patience," he says, "because they attend the meetings continuously. They not only observe…they ask questions and they heed our answers."
The negotiator was similarly positive about the roles played by the former president's adviser, whom he referred to as "not a novice", and billionaire envoy Steve Witkoff, whom he characterized as "a much wiser person than the simplified portrayal you see in the press".
The US, he asserted, will undertake a critical role in overseeing any future ceasefire, with capabilities encompassing orbital and other types of advanced surveillance.
"It is necessary to have someone who will serve as adjudication, for the reason that if there is a violation there should be a neutral actor that is reliable [and] respected."
Previous and Present Oversight Challenges
During an eight-year period before Russia's full-scale invasion in recent years, this oversight function was handled by the OSCE - a group whose limited means and absence of enforcement mechanisms rendered it mostly incapable of averting an intensification.
"That was no small feat [for them] simply to have two UAVs airborne over the area," Kyslytsya said. "It resembles the stone age period in contrast with what we have today."
In comparison, recent reports suggest that up to 12,000 drones are active over the urban center of a frontline city at any given moment.
An Insider's Perspective on Confronting the Opposition
Inquired about his ability to negotiate directly from delegates from a leader in the Kremlin who has shown readiness to sacrifice over a million-plus of his country's soldiers to conquer its neighbor, the diplomat, also a former UN ambassador, offered his response.
He explained that he'd had a long time of practice.
"I saw far more difficult situations. I spent a five-year term in at the UN, a portion before the major war. I regularly had to sit in the room with the adversary on a frequent basis."
One evening is seared in his recollection: 23 February 2022.
In the middle of an emergency Security Council session, convened to discuss the urgent crisis in Ukraine, the ambassador received news that his homeland was being assaulted.
At the same time, seven time zones to the eastward in Kyiv, initial far-off explosions were heard as the total assault on the nation commenced.
Amid moments of intense tension, the ambassador tried to persuade his Russian counterpart, the Russian envoy, to call his boss, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, to obtain guarantees that Moscow's forces would not cross the border.
"I've already said everything that I am aware of now," Nebenzia replied, according to his Ukrainian colleague. "I will not disturb the minister at this time."
The world changed at that instant. Kyslytsya stayed at the United Nations for another three years before going back to Kyiv.
The Path Forward
If the negotiating teams meet again in Switzerland this week, he'll be there, still thrashing out the contours and mechanics of a ceasefire but waiting all the while for the most important element of the jigsaw to fall into place.
"The war might be stopped by simply a single order of an individual to his military chief of staff," he stated.
"But apparently, the Russian president [Vladimir Putin] is not prepared for ending the conflict at present."